Oct 12th 2023
Water Treatment: Embracing Automation for Sustainable Growth
Access to clean water, one of the most critical resources for life, is facing increasing pressures due to rapid urbanization, industrialization, and climate change. As the global population continues to grow, the demand for clean water is expected to rise by 55% by 2050, according to the United Nations. Meanwhile, 20% of the world's groundwater sources are at risk of overexploitation, exacerbating the scarcity of freshwater resources. Therefore, ensuring the availability of freshwater is an imminent challenge that demands urgent attention on a global scale.
The first step in mitigating water scarcity would be to revamp the aging water treatment infrastructure and integrate them with innovative solutions to improve the efficiency of the water treatment process. Automation has emerged as a game-changer across numerous industries, and water treatment is no exception. The adoption of automation technologies such as Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) systems, Internet of Things (IoT) devices, Artificial Intelligence (AI) algorithms, and PLCs (Programmable Logic Controllers) have the potential to revolutionize the water treatment sector.
This article delves into the current challenges faced by the water treatment industry and the transformative potential of automation in each stage of freshwater treatment (Mixing, Coagulation and Flocculation, Sedimentation, Filtration, and Disinfection or Chlorination). We will also explore the impact of automation on business economics, listing various Automation technologies, real-world case studies, and best practices to establish the importance of automation in water treatment, and how we can leverage its benefits for a sustainable and competitive future.
Water Treatment Plants - Targets and the Current Challenges:
A typical water treatment plant aims to:
- Provide a consistent supply of clean and safe drinking water to its locality and ensure public health and safety through effective water management.
- Comply with local and national water quality standards.
- Minimize water wastage and promote resource conservation.
- Implement environmentally sustainable treatment processes.
- Optimize operational efficiency and reduce costs.
Although many water treatment plants struggle to accomplish one or more of their established goals, it is crucial to examine the operational and maintenance challenges that impede the successful fulfillment of a water treatment plant's objectives:
- Aging infrastructure: Outdated infrastructure in many water treatment plants often leads to inefficiencies, leaks, and system failures, which must be addressed through costly upgrades and maintenance.
- Limited resources and funding for improving efficiency and capacity expansion: Securing adequate funding for infrastructure improvements, technology implementation, and workforce training is a significant challenge. The growing global population and increasing urbanization also put significant pressure on water treatment plants to meet the ever-rising demand for clean water.
- Stringent environmental regulations: Compliance with increasingly strict water quality standards and environmental regulations requires close monitoring of operations, with continuous control and logging of historical data.
- Scarcity of water resources and changing climatic conditions: Water scarcity, extreme weather events, and changing precipitation patterns due to climate change pose operational challenges and require adaptive planning.
- Workforce management: Attracting, retaining, and training skilled professionals for the water treatment sector can be challenging, given the technical nature of the work and the need for specialized knowledge.
Need for Adopting Technology and Automation in Water Treatment Plants:
To mitigate the above-said challenges and ensure efficient and secure operations, adhering to a stringent regulatory framework, it is crucial for treatment plants to adopt technology and automation across all stages of the lifecycle. This includes:
- Employing engineering tools and expertise to facilitate cost-effective and timely changes to cater to variable water demand.
- Utilizing automated and integrated systems to provide real-time, continuous, and comprehensive control, visualization, and reporting capabilities for the entire operation.
- Implementing support mechanisms such as Data monitoring, Predictive maintenance models, and Automated alarm systems to maximize uptime and enhance plant performance.
Water Treatment Operation - Types and Stages:
Water treatment stages may vary depending on the source of water, either surface water or groundwater:
- Surface Water Treatment: Typically, surface water contains more suspended particles, organic matter, and microorganisms, making the coagulation, flocculation, and sedimentation stages crucial for effective treatment. Additionally, surface water treatment often requires more stringent disinfection processes to ensure the removal of various pathogens.
- Groundwater Treatment: Groundwater generally has fewer suspended particles and microorganisms compared to surface water, but it may contain higher levels of dissolved minerals, such as iron or manganese. In such cases, the treatment process may include additional stages, like aeration or ion exchange, to address specific contaminants. Disinfection requirements for groundwater are often less stringent, as it is less susceptible to microbial contamination.
Stages in a Water Treatment Plant:
Depending on the water source and its specific characteristics, the treatment process may need to be tailored to address the unique challenges associated with each type of water. Typically, the following five treatment stages are common across water treatment plants:
- Mixing: Addition of chemicals to raw water, which is mixed thoroughly to neutralize suspended particles and promote coagulation.
- Coagulation and Flocculation: Coagulants are added to form larger particles (flocs) that can be easily removed during sedimentation.
- Sedimentation: Flocs settle at the bottom of a sedimentation basin, allowing clarified water to pass through for further treatment.
- Filtration: Water is passed through a granular medium, like sand or activated carbon, to remove remaining suspended particles and contaminants.
- Disinfection or Chlorination: Disinfectants like chlorine or ultraviolet (UV) light are used to kill harmful microorganisms, ensuring safe drinking water.
Each stage of treatment must comply with regulations to ensure that the water properties (chemical, biological, and other parameters - color, odor, etc.) are within prescribed limits.
An Overview of US EPA Rules for Water Treatment:
The United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has established various norms and regulations for water treatment plants to ensure the safety and quality of drinking water supplied to the public. Some of the important EPA regulations for water treatment plants include:
- National Primary Drinking Water Regulations (NPDWR): The NPDWR covers various contaminants, including microorganisms, disinfectants, disinfection byproducts, inorganic chemicals, organic chemicals, and radionuclides.
- National Secondary Drinking Water Regulations (NSDWR): While these contaminants do not pose direct health risks, they can affect the taste, odor, or appearance of water, as well as cause staining or scaling. Examples of parameters covered under NSDWR include iron, manganese, chloride, and pH.
- Treatment Technique Requirements: For some contaminants, the EPA establishes treatment techniques rather than MCLs. Treatment techniques are specific procedures or processes that water treatment plants must follow to reduce the levels of certain contaminants. For instance, the Surface Water Treatment Rule (SWTR) requires plants treating surface water or groundwater under the direct influence of surface water to filter and disinfect the water to remove or inactivate pathogens like viruses, bacteria, and protozoa.
- Monitoring and Reporting Requirements: Water treatment plants must regularly monitor and test water quality parameters to demonstrate compliance with EPA regulations. They must also report the results of these tests to state or federal authorities and notify the public in case of any violations.
- Public Notification Rule: The EPA mandates that water suppliers inform their customers about any violations of the SDWA regulations, and any potential risks associated with the drinking water supply. This includes providing information on contaminants detected, potential health effects, and actions taken to address the issue.
Automation Technologies for Each stage of Water Treatment:
Each stage of the water treatment process can benefit from the implementation of automation technologies. Following is a brief overview of each stage and relevant automation technologies:
Stage - 1 (Mixing):
Mixing is the initial stage in the water treatment process, where chemicals are added to raw water to destabilize and neutralize suspended particles. Proper mixing ensures an even distribution of chemicals and optimal reaction.
Automation Technologies for Mixing:
- Automated dosing systems: These systems can precisely control the concentration of chemicals added to the water by evaluating the chemical characteristics in real time. This ensures accurate and consistent dosing and avoids excess addition of chemicals.
- PLC and SCADA systems: By monitoring and analyzing various parameters like flow rate and turbidity, SCADA systems can adjust the mixing process in real-time to maintain optimal conditions.
Stage - 2 (Coagulation and Flocculation):
This stage involves the addition of chemicals to form larger particles called flocs, which can be more easily removed during sedimentation.
Automation Technologies for Coagulation and Flocculation:
- Automated chemical dosing: Similar to mixing, automated dosing systems can control the amount of coagulant and flocculant chemicals added, ensuring effective and efficient particle agglomeration.
- Process Sensors: Sensors monitor key parameters such as pH, temperature, and particle size, adjusting the process in real-time to maintain optimal coagulation and flocculation conditions.
- IoT and Remote Monitoring: Process sensor data can be integrated with Gateways to feed the real-time water parameters into Cloud. This enables operators to remotely visualize the data and control the addition of Coagulants into the water in the case of an emergency.
Stage 3 - Sedimentation:
Sedimentation is the process where flocs settle at the bottom of a sedimentation basin, allowing clarified water to pass through for further treatment.
Automation Technologies for Sedimentation:
- IoT, Sensors, and Cloud Monitoring: These devices can monitor water quality parameters such as turbidity and suspended solids, providing data to optimize sedimentation conditions and prevent overflow.
- Automated sludge removal systems: By automating the removal of settled sludge, plants can minimize the need for manual intervention and maintain consistent sedimentation performance.
Stage 4 - Filtration:
Filtration is the process of passing water through a granular medium, such as sand or activated carbon, to remove remaining suspended particles and contaminants.
Automation Technologies for Filtration:
- Pressure sensors and flow meters: These devices can monitor filter performance by measuring pressure drops and flow rates, alerting operators to potential issues such as filter clogging or breakthrough.
- Automated backwash systems: By automating the backwashing process, plants can maintain optimal filtration performance and minimize the risk of filter failure.
- Solenoid valves and PLC-controlled operation: In the case of filter clogging, Solenoid valves receiving feedback from PLCs can diffuse pressure build-ups and re-route the water and can avoid disastrous leakages.
Stage 5 - Disinfection or Chlorination:
Disinfection or chlorination is the final stage of the water treatment process, where disinfectants such as chlorine or ultraviolet (UV) light are used to kill harmful microorganisms, ensuring the water is safe for consumption.
Automation Technologies for Disinfection or Chlorination:
- Automated addition of Chlorine: Precise control of disinfectant levels is critical for effective disinfection. Higher concentration of Chlorine is harmful to humans, while lesser concentrations are ineffective in controlling bacterial contamination. Therefore, integrating automated dosing systems can ensure accurate and consistent dosing, maintaining water safety standards.
- Online monitoring systems: By continuously monitoring disinfectant residuals and other water quality parameters, these systems can alert operators to potential issues and enable real-time adjustments to the disinfection process.
Use of Automation and Associated Technologies in other Sections of the Water Treatment Plant:
In addition to treatment stages, automation and its related technologies can also be integrated to other areas of water treatment to improve overall plant efficiency, these technologies include:
- Automated Solenoid Valves and Water Distribution Systems: Automation technologies, such as SCADA systems and IoT devices, can be used to control water distribution networks via Solenoid Valves, ensuring consistent pressure and flow rates, detecting leaks, and managing pressure zones.
- VFD (Variable Frequency Drive) / Automated Motor - Pumping Stations: Automated pump control systems can optimize energy consumption by adjusting pump operation based on real-time demand and system pressure. Predictive maintenance technologies, such as vibration analysis and condition monitoring, can also help minimize downtime and extend the life of pumping equipment.
- Water Quality Monitoring: Automated water quality monitoring systems can continuously track key water quality parameters, such as pH, temperature, TDS (total dissolved solids), BOD (Biological Oxygen demand), and turbidity, at various points throughout the treatment and distribution process. This real-time data can help operators make informed decisions and quickly respond to potential water quality issues.
- Integration with Manual and Motorized Ball Valves: To ensure the smooth operation of monitoring systems, manual ball valves can be incorporated for manual control over the flow, while electric actuated ball valves offer automated flow control solutions. These valves provide operators with the flexibility to manage water flow as needed, ensuring optimal monitoring conditions. Discover a wide selection of manual and motorized ball valves at electricsolenoidvalves.com.
- Wastewater Treatment: In addition to freshwater treatment, automation also plays a critical role for wastewater treatment processes, including activated sludge systems, biological nutrient removal, and membrane bioreactors. With such technologies integrated with continuous monitoring of key parameters and controlling equipment operation, automated systems can optimize treatment efficiency, reduce energy consumption, and maintain compliance with discharge regulations.
- Asset Management with Real-time monitoring and integrated Visual and Audio Alarm systems: IoT sensors and AI-powered analytics can be used to monitor the condition of critical assets, such as pipes, pumps, and valves, enabling proactive maintenance and minimizing the risk of unexpected failures. These technologies can also help water utilities optimize capital investments and prioritize infrastructure upgrades based on real-time asset performance data.
- Smart Meters: Automation technologies offer plants the ability to monitor and track water supply for each delivery point with Smart Water Meters to eliminate manual interventions in billing, identifying supply issues in real-time, and supply logbooks.
- Energy Management: With automated cut-off and tripping systems, automated solutions ensure minimal use of energy and optimize energy consumption by adjusting processes based on real-time data and implementing energy-efficient technologies. Treatment plants can significantly reduce their energy usage and associated costs with automation.
Case-Studies:
Background: The Greater Wellington Regional Council (GWRC) in New Zealand faced challenges in collecting process data from disparate data sources within their advanced water treatment system. The system, consisting of four automated water treatment plants, 15 pumping stations, and over 180 kilometers of pipeline, relied on a supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) system. Manual data extraction and organization were time-consuming and inefficient for required governmental compliance reports. GWRC sought a faster, more accurate, and automated reporting system with data validation capability and a 10-year data retention period.
Solution: GWRC implemented Rockwell Automation’s FactoryTalk® Historian Site Edition (SE) and FactoryTalk VantagePoint Enterprise Manufacturing Intelligence (EMI) software. The solution facilitated the creation of 11 automatically generated reports on various aspects of water treatment and consumption. Stakeholders, including analysts, engineers, business managers, and committee members, could access data through a single portal with secure login via a web browser.
- Improved efficiency and accuracy: Reports that previously took days to create and validate could now be produced within minutes or even seconds.
- Informed decision-making: Access to real-time data enables stakeholders to make better decisions based on accurate production metrics and resolve issues more quickly.
- Leak detection and prevention: Real-time data availability allowed quick identification and resolution of leaks before they escalated, saving resources, and preventing potential service disruptions.
- Public awareness and conservation: GWRC now offers a live map of the current rate of water supply, updated every 15 minutes, to encourage water conservation among residents.
The study demonstrates the benefits of automation in water treatment, highlighting the importance of efficient data management and reporting systems in improving operations and encouraging sustainable water usage.
Case Study #2: EMWD's Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning Pilot for Sustainability Goals
Background: The Eastern Municipal Water District (EMWD) in Southern California planned for the integration of automation for energy efficiency and cost reduction in its water and wastewater treatment plants. With the increasing demand for water and the need to maintain high-quality standards, EMWD sought to leverage emerging technologies, such as artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML), to optimize their water treatment processes, reduce energy consumption, and improve overall operational efficiency.
Solution: A pilot project was initiated to implement AI-enabled control systems and ML algorithms in their existing control systems, allowing for real-time monitoring and data analysis. The AI application was remotely programmed on an Allen‑Bradley® CompactLogix™ 5480 controller and installed on the existing plant automation network. The algorithms analyzed historical and real-time data from various sensors and equipment to identify patterns, trends, and anomalies.
- Reduced aeration basin airflow: The AI-driven optimization resulted in a 31% reduction in the airflow delivered to the aeration basin.
- Significant energy savings: The optimized process led to an estimated savings of 2,330 kWh of electricity per day, translating to over $100,000 in annual savings.
- Enhanced process control: The AI application allowed for better control over various aspects of the treatment process, enabling the facility to establish more aggressive setpoints.
- Improved effluent quality: The AI-driven optimization contributed to better water quality, with fewer incidents of ammonia bleed-through.
- Reduced disinfectant usage: The improved water quality reduced the need for disinfectants in the treatment process.
- Minimal staff interventions: The AI application managed the aeration process without the need for staff interventions, allowing personnel to focus on other tasks.
The case study demonstrates the benefits of incorporating AI technology into water treatment facilities' automation systems, emphasizing the potential for significant improvements in energy efficiency, process control, and water quality.
Economic Benefits of Implementing Automation and AI-driven Models to Treatment Plants:
The implementation of automation and AI-driven models in water treatment plants offers several direct and indirect economic benefits that can enhance the overall efficiency and cost-effectiveness of water management system:
Direct Benefits:
- Energy savings: Reduced energy consumption due to optimized operations, leading to lower energy costs.
- Reduced chemical usage: Optimized chemical dosing ensures the right amounts are used, decreasing expenses on chemicals.
- Operational efficiency: Automated processes lead to increased efficiency, reducing labor costs and manual errors.
- Proactive maintenance: AI-driven solutions enable early detection of potential equipment failures, minimizing downtime and maintenance costs.
- Remote monitoring and reduced use of manual labor: Automation can replace manual labor, especially for repetitive and hazardous tasks.
Indirect Benefits:
- Regulatory Compliance and Improved water quality: Enhanced process control and optimization contribute to better water quality, ensuring compliance with regulatory standards.
- Environmental impact: Reduced energy consumption and chemical usage contribute to the plant's sustainability goals, minimizing environmental footprint.
- Enhanced data-driven decision-making: Access to real-time data and insights allows for better decision-making, leading to long-term cost savings and performance improvements.
- Improved Public Health and Customer Satisfaction: Consistent, high-quality water supply improves customer satisfaction, potentially leading to increased revenue and a positive brand reputation.
Challenges to the Implementation of Automation in Water Treatment Plants:
Though automation is proven to provide multivarious benefits of the water treatment industry, implementing technology, or integrating with the existing systems comes with certain challenges such as:
- High initial investment: Upfront costs for installing advanced automation systems and technologies can be substantial.
- Integration Technology with existing systems: Ensuring compatibility and seamless integration with older infrastructure and control systems can be challenging.
- Skilled workforce: Training and maintaining a workforce with the necessary skills to operate and maintain automation technologies may be difficult.
- Data security and privacy: Protecting sensitive data and ensuring system security from potential cyber threats is critical.
Despite these initial challenges, research and current technologies are actively bridging ways to overcome these challenges and simplify adoption of automation.
Summary:
In conclusion, the growing demand for clean water and aging plant infrastructure, and stringent regulations highlight the importance and urgency of adopting automation in water treatment plants.
The integration of automation technologies, such as AI-driven solutions, IoT devices, Solenoid Valves, and advanced control systems, not only enhances efficiency and cost-effectiveness but also contributes to the long-term sustainability of water management systems. As the global population continues to rise and the need for clean water increases, the future of water treatment will heavily rely on automation technologies to overcome challenges, optimize operations, and ensure a reliable supply of high-quality water for generations to come.